Medium Close Up
This is a successful image as it is shot from the waist up, which is what is known as a medium close-up. This image would be successful on the front cover of a magazine as, through research, I have found that the typical shot used for a front cover is medium close up.
Close Up
This is a successful image in the sense that it was supposed to be shot as a close up, although it would not be as successful as a medium close up on a front cover as it is too close to the artist and does not leave much room for text.
Long Shot
Similar to the close up, this image is successful in that it was supposed to be a long shot, but would not be as successful on the cover of a magazine. This is because it is too far away from the model which means there would be very little emotion in the image and also means that there is a risk of having too much empty space on the magazine, making it look quite amateur and uninteresting.
Two Shot
This two shot would be successful on a front cover if it were showing a bad or partnership in music etc. This is because it is framed as a medium-long shot and so isn't too far away that you can't see their emotions and also can see how they are dressed, which fans of artists tend to be very interested in.
Example of bad lighting
For a pop magazine this image would be very unsuccessful as the lighting is very dark and goes against all conventions of the pop genre. The shadows on her face connote the idea of a darker genre such as indie or rock and so would be misleading to the target audience.
Example of good lighting
This would be good lighting to use for a pop magazine as the light makes the model look bright and would emphasise any bright colours that they would be wearing. It also makes sure that the model is the main focus of the image and would be very difficult to find a distraction.
Badly framed
This would be unsuccessful on a magazine as the photo does not leave much room for a masthead, feature stories or any of the conventional elements. Also, it doesn't fit with the pop genre as it slightly disorientates the audience and younger audience may find this off putting.